Shop our Amish kitchen
From the hills of Holmes County to the farmhouses of Lancaster and the woodshops of Shipshewana — pies, pantry goods, smoked meats and hand-carved wood, gathered in one place and shipped to your door.
Pies & Pastries
The heart of every Amish kitchen — hand-folded fried pies, whole-apple dumplings, shoofly, snitz and sugar cream.
BestsellerShips nowFried Pies — Classic 6-Pack
Hand-folded turnovers with flaky crust and a glossy sugar shell. Choose any 6: apple, peach, cherry, blackberry, lemon, raisin.
Ships nowFried Pies — Orchard 12-Pack
A full dozen of our hand-folded fried pies — perfect for sharing, gifting, or stocking the freezer.
BestsellerShips nowApple Dumplings — 4-Pack
Whole Holmes County apples wrapped in flaky pastry and baked in cinnamon-brown-sugar syrup.
Coming soonShoofly Pie
The Lancaster classic — molasses base, sticky middle, crumbly brown-sugar top.
Coming soonSnitz Pie
Dried-apple pie spiced with cinnamon and a hint of orange — a true Amish wedding pie.
Coming soonSugar Cream Pie
Indiana "Hoosier" pie — silky vanilla cream filling with a butter-brown top.
Coming soonPeanut Butter Pie
Whipped peanut-butter filling on a graham crust with chocolate drizzle.
Coming soonChicken Pot Pie
Hearty PA-Dutch pot pie — pulled chicken, broth-soaked squares, potatoes and herbs.
Donuts, Breads & Breakfast
Sourdough loaves, sticky buns, hand-cut egg noodles, and the cinnamon caramel donuts folks call "Amish Crack."
Coming soonCinnamon Caramel Donuts (½ dozen)
Pillowy yeast donuts rolled in cinnamon sugar and drizzled with caramel — the ones they call "Amish Crack."
Coming soonLong John Donuts (½ dozen)
Cream-filled, maple-glazed bar donuts. A Shipshewana bakery staple.
Coming soonSticky Buns (4-pack)
Pecan-studded, brown-sugar caramel, baked in cast iron.
Coming soonAmish Sourdough Loaf
Slow-fermented, hand-shaped, baked dark.
Coming soonHomemade Egg Noodles (1 lb)
Rolled, cut and dried on the farm. Cooks in minutes.
Coming soonButtermilk Pancake Mix
Two-pound bag — just add eggs, milk, and butter.
Cookies & Sweet Treats
Jumbo whoopie pies with creamy filling, monster cookies, snickerdoodles and frosted church cookies.
Coming soonClassic Whoopie Pies (6-pack)
Two pillowy chocolate cakes with a thick swirl of creamy filling.
Coming soonPumpkin Whoopie Pies (6-pack)
Spiced pumpkin cakes with cream-cheese filling.
Coming soonMonster Cookies (1 dozen)
Oats, peanut butter, M&Ms, and chocolate chips — soft and chewy.
Coming soonSnickerdoodles (1 dozen)
Crinkled tops, cinnamon-sugar coat, butter-soft middles.
Coming soonFrosted Church Cookies (1 dozen)
Soft sugar cookies with pastel buttercream, sprinkles on top.
Jams, Preserves & Pantry
Slow-cooked apple butter, mason-jar preserves, raw honey, maple syrup, salsa, pickles and GMO-free Amish popcorn.
Sold out — more comingSlow-Cooked Apple Butter
Holmes County apples cooked low and slow with cinnamon and clove. 16 oz jar.
Sold out — more comingStrawberry Preserves
Whole-berry, low-sugar preserves. 16 oz mason jar.
Sold out — more comingWild Blackberry Jam
Foraged blackberries cooked into a deep, dark jam. 16 oz.
Sold out — more comingPeach Jam
Late-summer peaches, lightly sweetened. 16 oz.
Sold out — more comingPepper Jelly
Sweet & spicy red-pepper jelly — pour over cream cheese.
Coming soonRaw Wildflower Honey
Unfiltered, single-source from Lancaster apiaries. 1 lb.
Coming soonPure Maple Syrup
Grade A amber — tapped, boiled, and bottled by hand. 12 oz.
Coming soonAmish Popcorn (GMO-free)
Tiny, tender hulls. Pops up snow-white. 2 lb bag.
Smoked Meats & Artisan Cheese
Hickory-smoked jerky and summer sausage, thick-cut bacon, smoked ham and artisan cheese from Yoder's in Shipshewana.
Coming soonHickory Smoked Beef Jerky
Hand-cut whole-muscle beef, smoked low over hickory. 6 oz.
Coming soonSummer Sausage
Coarse-ground beef and pork with mustard seed. 1 lb stick.
Coming soonSmoked Ham Steak
Bone-in, sugar-cured, hickory-smoked. 2 lb.
Coming soonThick-Cut Hickory Bacon
Cured 10 days, smoked 12 hours. 1 lb pack.
Coming soonYoder's Artisan Cheese
Hand-cut wedge from Shipshewana — pick mild, sharp, or smoked.
Kitchen Utensils & Wood Goods
Hand-carved walnut and cherry from small Amish woodshops — spoons, rolling pins, cutting boards and butter molds, made the old way.
Coming soonHand-Carved Wooden Spoon Set
Three cherry-wood cooking spoons, hand-finished with food-safe oil.
Coming soonWalnut Rolling Pin
Solid black walnut, turned on a foot-treadle lathe.
Coming soonEnd-Grain Cutting Board
Walnut and maple checkerboard, 12" x 16". Built to last a lifetime.
Coming soonHand-Carved Butter Mold
Wheat-sheaf pattern, the way grandmothers pressed it.
Coming soonHand-Dipped Taper Candles (pair)
Beeswax, dipped over a kitchen kettle. Honey-warm glow.
Baskets & Textiles
Oak-splint market baskets, flour-sack towels, quilted potholders, and full-bib aprons in classic Amish patterns.
Coming soonOak-Splint Market Basket
Hand-woven, leather-bound handle. Holds two pies easily.
Coming soonBread Basket
Shallow oval — the perfect table basket for warm rolls.
Coming soonFlour-Sack Dish Towels (set of 4)
Soft cotton, lint-free, hand-hemmed. Just like grandma's.
Coming soonQuilted Potholders (pair)
Patchwork, double-layered cotton batting.
Coming soonClassic Amish Bib Apron
Full bib, two pockets, hand-sewn in a Lancaster sewing circle.
Gift Sets & Bundles
Hand-packed boxes for friends, family or your own pantry — sampler boxes, baker's boxes and holiday crates.
Coming soonThe Sampler Box
6 fried pies + 2 apple dumplings + 1 jar of jam, packed in a kraft gift box.
Coming soonThe Baker's Box
Walnut rolling pin + end-grain board + pancake mix + raw honey.
Coming soonThe Pantry Box
Three preserves + apple butter + Amish popcorn + a pound of egg noodles.
Coming soonThe Holiday Gift Crate
Assorted pies + beeswax candles + oak-splint basket + four preserves. Ships in a wooden crate.